Away from home

The crisis facing Italian bars and the recipe for recovery in the face of falling consumer spending

The number of traditional-style establishments is down by 15 per cent compared with 2019, and customer spending has fallen by 2.4 per cent over the past two years (compared with a 1.7 per cent increase for the out-of-home sector as a whole). Welcoming venues and staff training are among the key areas for investment identified at a Fipe Confcommercio forum

6' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

6' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

Between 2019 and 2025, the number of businesses operating in Italian bars fell from almost 150,000 to just under 125,000, a decrease of around 15 per cent, according to an analysis by Fipe Confcommercio based on Infocamere data, which takes into account both businesses that have ceased trading and those that have ‘migrated’ to other catering models. In the most recent year under review, the number of outlets fell by 1.5 per cent, and of the businesses established in 2020, only 55 per cent are still operating.

The picture painted today, Tuesday 17 November, by the Italian Federation of Public Establishments at the Palazzo delle Esposizioni in Rome, during the first “Italian Bar Forum”, is not a rosy one: between 2023 and 2025 the value of spending in bars fell by 2.4 per cent, whilst the entire out-of-home market rose by 1.7 per cent (source: Tradelab).

Loading...

For the president of Fipe , Lino Enrico Stoppani , the gap is also due to the different trajectories of restaurants, which in recent years – despite the economic crisis – have benefited from a significant boost to their image: the UNESCO recognition of Italian cuisine, Restaurant Day, and coverage in the press and food guides. Coffee served at the bar has been left behind and has found itself playing the role of the ‘poor relation of the hospitality sector’.

Low to medium average spend

Not all bar closures mean permanent closures: some have reinvented themselves, moving towards other models of catering and more profitable business models. In fact, the bars’ total turnover of 23 billion is worth less than a quarter of the total, despite accounting for over half of all visits. The crux of the matter lies in the profit and loss account. The average bill is €4.20, falling to €2.90 for breakfast, compared with €11.50 for lunch and €7.30 for an evening aperitif.
However, more than 60 per cent of customers are concentrated between breakfast and the mid-morning break – the times that are least profitable for establishments that serve an average of around 120 customers a day and remain open for 14 hours. Staff costs and utility bills are the biggest expenses, Stoppani points out, whilst rents are adjusted in line with ISTAT indices.

Andrea Illy: ‘Coffee remains key, thanks to service, atmosphere and quality’

Andrea Illy, chairman of Illycaffè and a Fipe board member, cites market saturation as one of the causes of closures: in Italia there are 2.7 cafés per thousand inhabitants (Tradelab), a legacy of urban tradition and reforms that have led to ‘uncontrolled proliferation’. Only a small proportion of business owners have focused on high quality, whilst the majority have resorted to cutting costs, thereby worsening the atmosphere, service and products and driving customers away. This has created a vicious circle: fewer customers, further spending cuts, and even fewer customers. Meanwhile, prices are set to rise by 3 per cent in 2026, with coffee shop prices up 2.8 per cent in September and a cup of coffee costing 1.28 euros. Yet the sector remains resilient in terms of employment: 374,000 workers, of whom 276,730 are employees, up 6.4 per cent on 2024 (Fipe, based on Istat and INPS data).

More than one in four drinks served at a café is a coffee, and when you include cappuccinos and water, this figure rises to 45 per cent of the total, according to data from Tradelab. For Illy, the cup of coffee remains the linchpin of the café, even more so than he himself had expected: ‘Coffee plays a pivotal – indeed, decisive – role in the café. Without coffee,’ he explains, ‘breakfast loses its meaning, and this applies to adults as much as it does to young people. Aperitifs and midday snacks have done nothing to undermine this connection.’

Focusing on speciality coffees

According to Illy, price is not one of the problems plaguing our local cafés: the Italian cup of coffee, it argues, is among the cheapest in coffee-consuming countries (€1.28 on average, according to Fipe). At that price point the café owner does not earn enough and often cuts costs, so the atmosphere and service deteriorate, customers drift away and takings fall even further. To break out of this downward spiral, a strategy ‘based on value rather than price’ is needed. Value must therefore be sought elsewhere. Illy adds that 90 per cent of Italians are already satisfied with the quality of the coffee served, whilst customers are looking for a pleasant atmosphere, cleanliness and decor, as well as good service and courtesy.

Coffee, however, can always evolve as an experience: speciality coffee, inspired by Italian traditions, which has become widespread in recent decades, has turned it into “an experiential product to be discovered and savoured”, just like wine. Before, he recalls, it was a functional drink: people were after the caffeine, not the quality. What holds it all together, though, is the relationship: a very high proportion of people have a favourite café, where the barista knows the customer and serves them their coffee without asking any questions.

The crucial role of industry and training

The industry plays a central role. According to Illy, product improvement depends on ‘a major alliance between the industry and the hospitality sector’, within a ‘public-private partnership’ with the government.

Training is also needed, because baristas do not have a recognised course of study: illycaffè’s University of Coffee was established in response to a need that arose whilst exporting to Japan, where, years later, Illy found excellent examples of the Italian coffee ritual being performed. “A sector representing 5 billion consumption occasions a year in Italia deserves – he emphasises – an industrial policy and incentives to modernise premises.”

Loading...

Not to mention that this value can then cross borders. For Illy, the world’s coffee shops represent the greatest ‘Italian-sounding’ phenomenon that has ever existed, and those who try the imitation tend to ‘trade up’ to the authentic version, just as happens with ‘Parmesan’, after which people choose Parmigiano Reggiano PDO. After all, these establishments, wherever they are in the world, revolve around the barista, espresso and cappuccino, with images of Rome and Florence on the walls.

Turning crisis into progress and exports

The opportunity lies in exporting the original and authentic Italian bar format, including through international partnerships and groups.

“The Italian bar is a unique economic and social model, capable of bringing together business, employment, service and community,” argues Stoppani, “a sector undergoing profound transformation and evolution, yet one that operates on tight margins.” How can we revitalise it? By starting with demand, which is certainly not lacking. There are over 5 billion consumption occasions a year, around 16 million a day, accounting for 56 per cent of out-of-home visits. Not to mention the extensive network: 74 per cent of local authorities have at least one bar. More than one in four purchases is a coffee, and when combined with cappuccino and water, this accounts for 45 per cent of the total; alcoholic drinks remain below 10 per cent, whilst sweet treats account for almost twice as much as savoury items.

The ‘neighbourhood’ café remains central

Research carried out by Swg on behalf of Fipe, involving over 2,500 Italians, confirms the central role played by the local bar: 72 per cent visit it at least once a week, 25 per cent every day, and 66 per cent have a regular haunt. For 33 per cent, a bar open late in the suburbs enhances neighbourhood safety. However, the divide is growing: whilst 56 per cent believe there is a distinctly Italian way of experiencing the bar, 32 per cent feel this identity has faded or disappeared, and the idea of ‘being amongst others even when you’re on your own’ appeals to 14 per cent of Gen Z and Millennials, compared with 22 per cent of Gen X.

To emerge from the crisis, Stoppani is therefore focusing on quality, “because only by improving what we offer,” he argues, “can we increase turnover without cutting costs”. To back this up, Tradelab reports that a multi-specialist outlet has a receipt value twice that of a generalist one.

Three priorities and a Manifesto: the environment, service and product

According to Fipe, there are therefore three priorities for revitalising the Italian bar sector. The first concerns the environment and the refurbishment of premises: an industrial policy dossier is ready to be presented to the government and banks to secure financial support for the refurbishment of premises, both inside and out. The second is service: the role of the barista does not have a recognised educational pathway and needs to be revitalised as a profession, not least to rekindle young people’s interest in the trade. The third is the product, through a partnership between the industry and the hospitality sector.

Fipe has also drawn up a manifesto, the “New Etiquette of the Italian Bar”: there will be a sign to distinguish ‘authentic’ establishments from other formats, based on six key principles: quality, customer relations, refreshment, décor, ambience and atmosphere. This is confirmed by SWG research: cleanliness, attention to detail, service and a warm welcome are key factors in choosing a venue, and 71 per cent of Italians say they would be influenced by a certification scheme based on shared quality standards.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti