New EU tobacco regulations. Impact on Southern European countries
The Commission is working to tighten the regulations governing the supply chain for new products. The process is moving forward, but the review board has rejected the impact assessment for the second time. Report by the Research Department and NextMed: if implemented, turnover in Italia could fall by up to 27 per cent
Key points
2026 could see the introduction of a new European directive on tobacco and nicotine products. The Health Commissioner, Olivér Várhelyi, has also indicated his intention to present a draft (TPD3) at the end of December, though this remains subject to change. The change in the rotating presidency has slowed the process, but more importantly, in recent days a second negative opinion has been issued by the Regulatory Scrutiny Board. The body responsible for reviewing EU proposals, which assesses the substance of impact assessments for legislative initiatives, has written to Várhelyi stating, in essence, that there is currently a lack of in-depth analysis and data necessary to calculate the effects and repercussions on the industry. The Commission’s aim would be to introduce stricter measures than those in the current Tobacco Products Directive, treating e-cigarettes, pouches and new non-combustible products in the same way as traditional products. It would also like to introduce marketing restrictions.
Public consultations
In recent months, a public consultation was launched, attracting around 120,000 contributions from stakeholders and members of the public, the outcome of which was largely opposed to the proposal to go beyond the current regulations. Despite this outcome, informal consultations by the Directorate-General for Health have continued with representatives of parliamentary groups (with the exception of the EPP) and Member States. Italia appears to be strongly opposed. Meanwhile, the governments of the Netherlands, Belgium, Finland and France are said to have championed a further initiative that would entail freezing the current technological developments in place. This carries the implicit risk of preventing the market from evolving in any way and thus – paradoxically – bringing traditional blonde hair back into fashion. Behind the usual political clashes within the trilogue, however, lies a very different industrial stance between Northern and Southern Europe.
The Research Department’s report
A report currently being prepared by *Il Sole*’s Research Department, in collaboration with NextMed, clearly shows that the countries most affected by the TPD reform would be, in addition to Italy, Greece, Spain and Portugal. Mediterranean nations are those with the most developed tobacco supply chains and therefore with higher levels of employment and contribution to GDP. It should be noted that Italia is the EU’s leading producer of raw tobacco, its main manufacturing hub, and also stands out in the export figures for smoke-free products. The sector’s supply chain contributes 29.6 billion euros to GDP, supports 186,200 jobs and generates 15.7 billion in revenue from excise duties and VAT. The legislation in question, by contrast, would apply uniformly to all 27 Member States without taking into account geographical differences and, above all, the specific industrial and agricultural implications.
As early as last April, the board had raised several regulatory issues. These included the risk of an impact on the regulations in force in individual Member States and their respective tax systems. Although the Commission has guaranteed uniformity, the concern is the potential distorting effect on local markets. The same report by the Research Department of Sole/NextMed analyses negative repercussions in Italia of up to a 27 per cent drop in turnover within the sector. This would occur if the new legislation were essentially to reflect the WHO’s recommendations and guidelines. This is an important figure that cannot be ignored at this fluid stage of the debate. All the more so given that in November 2025, at COP11 in Geneva (the conference on tobacco control), the European Union had failed to reach a common position due to a WHO stance rejected by half of its member states, including Italia. Evidently out of fear of losing industrial competitiveness.
The legislative process and the coming months
At this stage, the process would still involve a series of steps. Following the Commission’s publication of the text, the national parliaments will be called upon to give their opinion on subsidiarity in the spring of 2027. Negotiations between the European Parliament and the Council would then begin. Furthermore, in parallel, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions will also be required to give their views. That is, provided that the second rejection by the Regulatory Scrutiny Board does not prompt specific responses from Várhely’s offices or explicit political interventions that highlight the divisions within Europe on this issue.


