Edufin month

Scams, costs, mistakes: how financial education protects savers

Financial Education Month kicks off: Italy tries to reduce the skills gap, but schools struggle to launch financial education initiatives

by Marco lo Conte

Giorgetti: "L'educazione finanziaria è un bene pubblico"

4' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

4' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

It is now a daily trickle: via e-mail, Whatsapp or the traditional text message, fraudsters attack our money. And those who are unable to recognise a genuine request for help from a family member from a bait thrown out by those who attack our money are at great risk. According to a recent survey almost 6 million Italians, about 10 per cent of the total, have suffered a financial scam in recent years (2.8 in 2024 alone). What is striking is that, according to experts, 83% of those scammed had no skills to protect them from fraud.

The ability to recognise a scam attempt is also part of the knowledge and skills that fall under the name of financial education: it means being able to protect one's money from the sights of the ill-intentioned, but also knowing how to make good decisions, identifying the lowest costs and best risk/return ratio, for example. As well as knowing how to make the right choices at the right time, avoiding, for example, procrastinating on pension choices, thus avoiding joining the pension instruments available to build a somewhat more serene future than those who procrastinate instead.

Loading...

For a number of years now, Financial Education Month, promoted in November by the Financial Education Committee, has been a moment of awareness-raising to raise attention to correct financial behaviour, curbing those that are harmful to our wealth and consequently to our life goals to be achieved with money.

Financial education has also entered schools in Italy: but only seven hours a year within the civic education curriculum. There are no results regarding the experiences put in place for the 2024/25 school year from a ministerial source: initiatives arise from the goodwill of teachers and from the subjects that engage the schools, associations, foundations, market players such as banks and insurance companies, newspapers such as Il Sole 24 Ore or such as the many creators that populate the web and social networks, becoming privileged interlocutors of the youngest.

Are these initiatives useful? There is some progress, albeit modest: according to the Bank of Italy, from 2020 to 2023, the level of financial literacy among adults in Italy has risen from 10.2 points to 10.7, on a scale of 0 to 20. Looking at the declination of financial education - knowledge, attitudes and behaviour - it is the latter that have risen the most (from 4.2 to 4.7 on a scale of 0 to 9), as have attitudes (from 2.0 to 2.3, on a scale of 0 to 4). By contrast, knowledge of the subject is slightly down (from 3.9 to 3.7), covering concepts such as inflation, simple and compound interest rates and risk diversification.

The level remains modest and is even more discouraging in an international comparison: among OECD countries, Italy is close to sufficient (60/100) but remains below average and well behind countries such as Germany or Ireland (76/100). It doesn't go any better for high school students: in 2022, the score of Italian students rises to 484 points, from 467 in 2012. Not that financial education is not an issue abroad: the challenges of a complex world like ours require more individual skills than in the past.

It is worth noting that the supply of financial goods and services shows a correlation between higher costs and lower levels of financial literacy: according to Morningstar, mutual funds in Italy have by far the highest costs, at 1.4% on average, while in Switzerland and the UK, average costs are less than 1%. This reflects a weak role of product demand in the financial market, dominated by a supply that is able to captively impose remunerative terms for itself, mirroring international scores and comparisons.

But there is another area in which the lack of financial education produces effects inconsistent with the needs of savers. And this emerges from the recent annual Acri Ipsos survey, entitled "Savings: protection, inclusion, development", conducted on the occasion of the 101st World Savings Day. What emerges is a panorama of decisions that shows contradictions, oddities and biases that together reveal a lack of ability to plan.

For example, those who manage to save report that: 1) more than a fifth state that they do not know where to invest 2) this percentage is historically decorrelated to market or economic trends (the peak was in 2019) and is therefore not justified by a moment of greater uncertainty than in the past 3) on the one hand, there is a surge in preferences for real estate reflecting traditional choices but involving non-negligible risks, in a context in which prices certainly do not appear affordable 4) and on the other hand, preferences for both so-called 'safe' and 'risky' instruments are falling (definitions that are also debatable), reflecting a poor ability to allocate one's resources for current and future needs. To which are added other attitudes that paint a sub-optimal picture: the low adherence to complementary pension schemes (around 30% of the total) and the atavistic low insurance coverage.

In short, the gap to be bridged is significant and the results of financial education are not immediate. Engaging students without training teachers is almost as difficult as engaging adults. But the risk of being cheated, paying excessive costs or even making the wrong choices for our future leads us to take every opportunity to improve our skills. The only way forward.

Copyright reserved ©
  • Marco lo Conte

    Marco lo ConteResponsabile per lo sviluppo delle attività video multimediali de Il Sole 24 Ore

    Luogo: Milano

    Lingue parlate: Inglese, francese, spagnolo

    Argomenti: social media, digital journalism, risparmio, previdenza, finanza comportamentale, educazione finanziaria

    Premi: Premio Federchimica "Per un futuro intelligente", 2001; Premio PrevAer 2019 per l’impegno a favore della cultura Previdenziale & Finanziaria

Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti